Car Insurance for Bad Credit: Costs, Rules & Tips

Most car insurers in most states look at your credit history when they price a policy. If your credit is poor, that can mean a noticeably higher premium, even with a clean driving record. It can also mean a longer shopping process, because insurers weigh credit differently.

This guide explains what insurers actually look at, how large the penalty tends to be, which states restrict the practice, and the steps that tend to bring a bad-credit quote down. Figures come from named sources with their dates, and anything we could not confirm firsthand is marked.

The quick answer

  • Insurers use a credit-based insurance score, not your FICO score. The NAIC says it is built from credit history but predicts insurance claims rather than loan repayment.
  • The cost can be large. Bankrate’s 2025 analysis, as reported in search summaries, put poor-credit drivers at about 76% more than good-credit drivers for full coverage. Studies differ, so treat that as a ballpark.
  • A few states restrict or prohibit it. California, Hawaii and Massachusetts are the clearest cases, and several other states limit how it can be used.
  • Shopping around matters more than usual. Insurers weight credit differently, so quotes for the same driver can differ widely.
  • You have rights. If credit information leads to worse terms, federal law requires a notice, and you can dispute errors on your report.

What a credit-based insurance score is

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) describes a credit-based insurance score as a number based partly or entirely on information from your credit history. Insurers use it to estimate how likely you are to file a claim. A traditional credit score predicts whether you will repay a loan, and an insurance score may weigh the same credit factors differently.

The NAIC cites FICO’s published breakdown for its own insurance score: payment history (40%), outstanding debt (30%), length of credit history (15%), pursuit of new credit (10%) and credit mix (5%). Other companies build their own models, so the weights an insurer uses may differ. The NAIC lists what is left out of these scores: race, religion, gender, marital status, age, income, occupation, where you live, and participation in credit counseling. Certain inquiries, such as checks of your own credit and promotional inquiries, are also excluded.

The score is one rating factor among many. For auto insurance, others include your driving record, ZIP code, age, vehicle, annual mileage, coverage limits and deductibles. The NAIC also cites a FICO estimate that about 95% of auto insurers use these scores in states where the practice is allowed.

Credit reports feed the score, which is why the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) matters here. The FTC notes that sellers of auto and home insurance rely on credit reports and sometimes call the result an insurance score.

How much bad credit can raise your premium

Published estimates vary, because each study uses different drivers, coverage levels and credit tiers.

SourceYearFindingNotes
Bankrate2025Poor credit about 76% more than good credit for full coverage, roughly $4,644 a year, or $2,006 moreSeen in search summaries; we could not open the full methodology
The Zebra2025Exceptional credit (823 and up) averaged $1,673 a year, poor credit (under 523) $6,254Seen in search summaries; the same source says moving up one credit tier lowered rates 54% on average
NPR, using Quadrant Information Services dataNov. 2025Credit history mattered far more in Florida than in Idaho, and State Farm appeared to weigh it more than ProgressiveReported summary of ZIP-code-level quotes

These figures are not interchangeable and none is a quote for you. The practical lesson from the NPR analysis is that the penalty depends on the state and the insurer. A gap of tens of percent in one place can be far smaller elsewhere. Bankrate’s analysis, for example, reportedly found North Carolina’s gap near 39% for full coverage.

States that ban or limit credit in auto insurance pricing

Not every state lets insurers use credit. The NAIC says some states restrict use or prohibit certain uses entirely and points readers to its state chart. Experian’s March 2025 summary of state rules lists the following. Laws change, so confirm with your state insurance department before relying on this.

StateWhat Experian reports
CaliforniaInsurers do not use credit-based scores or credit history to underwrite or rate auto policies
HawaiiAuto insurers cannot use credit ratings in underwriting standards or rating plans
MassachusettsCredit information and credit-based insurance scores are barred for rates, new business and renewals
MichiganCredit cannot be used to deny, cancel or refuse to renew coverage or to set auto rates; may be considered for installment payment options. Secondary sources disagree on how far the rule goes
MarylandCredit can help set the rate on a new policy but cannot be used to deny, cancel, refuse renewal or raise premiums at renewal
OregonCannot be the basis for cancellation or non-renewal; can factor into initial offers, with limits on which credit information is used
UtahCannot be the only factor in initial underwriting; after 60 days it cannot be used to cancel or refuse renewal, and can only be used to offer discounts

Other states, including Washington and Nevada, show up in some secondary sources, and Washington’s status has changed through litigation, so we are not listing them as confirmed. Most states allow credit use with guardrails. The NAIC says that in most states an insurer cannot use the score as the sole reason to raise rates or to deny, cancel or refuse to renew a policy.

Insurers often cited for poor credit

Rankings conflict, which is itself useful information. One analysis found in search results names Nationwide, GEICO and Travelers as cheapest for bad credit. Compare.com’s 2026 analysis names Country Financial. CNBC says GEICO had the cheapest average rates of the insurers it reviewed. We could not verify the underlying rates, so treat these names as starting points for quotes, not recommendations, and note that some of these insurers do not sell in every state. For a head-to-head on two large carriers, see Progressive vs. GEICO.

Non-standard insurers, which specialize in higher-risk drivers, are another option when standard insurers decline you or quote very high. They often accept drivers with violations or lapses in coverage, and the tradeoff can be fewer discounts or more restrictive terms. Our guide to high-risk auto insurance covers how that market works, and SR-22 insurance explains the filing some drivers need.

How to lower your costs with bad credit

  1. Compare at least three to five insurers. Because the weight on credit varies, a company that penalizes you heavily may be followed by one that does not. Ask each insurer for the same coverage limits and deductibles.
  2. Ask about telematics or usage-based programs. These price you partly on driving behavior such as braking, speed and mileage, which shifts attention from your credit file. Some programs work only for new customers, and some can raise rates for risky driving, so read the terms. See pay-per-mile car insurance for the low-mileage version.
  3. Raise your deductible, if you can afford it. A higher collision and comprehensive deductible lowers the premium. Keep enough in savings to pay it.
  4. Stack discounts. Ask about multi-policy, good student, defensive driving, safety features, paperless and autopay discounts. Eligibility varies by insurer. More ideas are in ways to lower insurance premiums.
  5. Pay in full if possible. Many insurers charge installment fees or price monthly plans higher. Experian notes that Michigan still lets insurers consider credit for installment payment options.
  6. Review the coverage you carry. Dropping collision on an older car may cost less than the car is worth, but state-required liability limits stay. Do not go below your state’s minimum.
  7. Improve your credit over time. The NAIC advises paying bills on time, catching up if behind and keeping card balances low. credit cards for building credit covers one way to build history.
  8. Ask about life circumstances. The NAIC says many insurers will reconsider a premium after a catastrophic event, job loss or serious illness. Some states formalize this, so ask your insurer and your state department of insurance.
  9. Re-shop at renewal and after credit improves. Rates are not locked to the score you had at signup. Ask the insurer to re-run your score.

Your rights when credit raises your rate

  • Adverse action notice. The FTC says that if a business denies you insurance or offers worse terms based on credit report information, federal law requires a notice naming the credit bureau, with its address and phone number, and including your credit score if it was a factor.
  • Ask what the insurer used. The NAIC says you can ask whether a credit-based insurance score was used to underwrite and rate your policy, and which risk category you were placed in.
  • Get your credit reports. You can get a free report every 12 months from Equifax, Experian and TransUnion through annualcreditreport.com, according to the NAIC.
  • Dispute errors. Ask the credit bureau to correct mistakes. In Michigan, for example, statute requires an insurer to reevaluate the insured within 30 days of notice that credit information was incorrect or incomplete, and refund overpayments. Other states have their own rules.

You can also check your auto insurance score to see what insurers may be looking at.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Accepting the first quote. With credit in the mix, results vary more than usual.
  • Letting coverage lapse. A gap in coverage can raise rates on its own.
  • Cutting coverage below the state minimum or below what a lender requires to save money.
  • Skipping the credit report check. An error can cost you for the length of a policy term.
  • Applying for many new credit accounts just before shopping. New credit is part of the score.
  • Assuming a ban applies to you. Check your state’s rules, since limits differ widely.
  • Assuming the cheapest quote on a comparison site is final. Rates can change after the insurer pulls your credit and driving record.

Frequently asked questions

Can I get car insurance with bad credit?

Yes. Poor credit may raise your premium, but insurers generally still sell policies, and non-standard insurers specialize in higher-risk drivers. In most states an insurer cannot use credit as the sole reason to deny, cancel or refuse to renew, according to the NAIC.

Does car insurance check your credit score?

Many insurers check a credit-based insurance score, which comes from your credit history. It is not the same as the score a lender uses. The NAIC cites a FICO estimate that about 95% of auto insurers use these scores where permitted.

Does an insurance quote hurt my credit?

Ask the insurer how it pulls your credit. The NAIC says certain inquiries, such as account reviews and promotional inquiries, are excluded from insurance scores, but we could not confirm how every insurer’s quote process is reported.

Which states do not allow credit in car insurance rates?

Experian’s March 2025 summary lists California, Hawaii and Massachusetts as barring credit use, with Michigan, Maryland, Oregon and Utah restricting it in varying ways. Check your state insurance department, as rules change.

How much more does bad credit cost?

Estimates vary. Bankrate’s 2025 analysis reportedly put poor-credit drivers about 76% above good-credit drivers for full coverage, while The Zebra’s 2025 averages were $1,673 for exceptional credit and $6,254 for poor credit. Your result depends on your state and insurer.

Will my rate go down if my credit improves?

It can. Ask your insurer to re-rate you after your credit improves, and re-shop at renewal. The Zebra reported that improving by one credit tier lowered rates by an average of 54%, though that is a national average, not a promise.

What can I do if my rate went up because of my credit?

Request the adverse action notice, ask which risk category you were placed in, check your credit reports and dispute errors. Then compare quotes from other insurers.

Are there insurers that do not use credit?

In states that ban credit use, no insurer can use it for rating. In other states policies vary, and some insurers or programs give less weight to credit. Ask each insurer directly and compare actual quotes.

Sources and a note on advice

Definitions, score factors, exclusions, consumer rights and the FICO usage estimate come from the NAIC’s credit-based insurance scores topic page (updated March 19, 2026) and its Consumer Insight article. The notice requirement comes from the FTC’s consumer page on credit scores. The state list comes from Experian’s March 2025 summary, and the Michigan reevaluation rule from MCL 500.2157. Premium figures come from Bankrate, The Zebra and NPR as reported in search summaries; we could not open every original report, so we have flagged them as secondhand. No insurer paid for placement, and we have no affiliate relationship with any company named. This is general information, not insurance or financial advice. Get quotes and confirm state rules before deciding.